Real Estate Investing Trends
The numbers behind the property

Strategies

Why Investors Drift Into Small Commercial

Owners of residential property often move into small commercial buildings because the leases shift operating obligations to tenants, though the vacancy risk is far less forgiving.

High-rise residential building with balconies and multiple windows in an urban setting.
High-rise residential building with balconies and multiple windows in an urban setting. · Photo via Pexels
Financial information notice. Analysis and education — not personalised financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

A recognisable path runs from residential rentals into small commercial property. The reasons are structural rather than fashionable, and so are the difficulties.

The lease structure is the attraction

Commercial leases commonly pass operating costs to the tenant, so taxes, insurance and maintenance are reimbursed rather than absorbed by the owner.

This narrows the gap between gross and net income and reduces the owner's exposure to cost inflation, since increases largely flow through to the occupant.

Lease terms are also longer, often measured in years rather than months, which means less frequent turnover and more predictable income while a tenant remains.

Management intensity falls

Commercial tenants generally maintain their own premises and handle their own interior issues, which removes most of the request volume a residential building generates.

There is no equivalent of the late-night repair call for most small commercial property, and the relationship is conducted on business rather than domestic terms.

The trade is that when something does require attention, it tends to be a larger question about the building envelope, systems or a lease negotiation.

Vacancy behaves very differently

A vacant apartment is re-let in weeks in most conditions. A vacant commercial unit can sit for many months, because the pool of suitable tenants is far smaller.

Fit-out requirements compound this. A new tenant frequently needs the space adapted, and the cost of that work is negotiated as part of the deal.

With few units in a small building, a single departure can remove a large share of the income, which makes the cash flow far less smooth than the lease term suggests.

Tenant credit becomes a real question

Residential screening looks at income and history. Commercial underwriting looks at a business, its trading record and whether it can survive the lease term.

A long lease is only as good as the tenant behind it, and a small business failing mid-term leaves the owner with a claim rather than income.

Guarantees, deposits and letters of credit exist to address this, and negotiating them is part of the leasing process rather than an afterthought.

Valuation is more income-driven

Small commercial buildings are valued primarily from income, with far fewer comparable sales available than residential property enjoys.

This makes lease quality directly visible in value. A building with a strong tenant on a long lease and one with a weak tenant on a short one are priced very differently.

It also means value moves with leasing outcomes rather than with the residential market, which is part of the diversification that draws owners in.

Alan Whitfield
Editor, Real Estate Investing Trends

Alan underwrote commercial real estate loans for eleven years. He now writes about the deals he would not have approved, and why people did them anyway.

More from Alan →

Also by Alan Whitfield

Strategies

Wholesaling, and what it actually involves

Contracting a property and assigning the contract for a fee is a real business with a marketing engine at its centre and a growing set of legal constraints.

Alan Whitfield··4 min read

Strategies

The first deal: a realistic sequence

Not a formula for wealth, just the order of operations that most successful first purchases have followed.

Rosa Delgado··4 min read