Real Estate Investing Trends
The numbers behind the property

Financing

What lenders look at besides the property

The property is one of four things being underwritten, and the other three are about you.

Professional woman in formal attire inspects an unfinished construction site. Ideal for real estate and construction themes.
Professional woman in formal attire inspects an unfinished construction site. Ideal for real estate and construction themes. · Photo via Pexels
Financial information notice. Analysis and education — not personalised financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Borrowers focus on whether the property qualifies. Lenders assess the property, the borrower's credit, the borrower's liquidity and the borrower's experience — and any of the four can stop a loan.

Credit

Score matters, and what sits behind it matters more on investor loans.

Lenders look at payment history, particularly any mortgage lates, which are weighted heavily. Recent derogatory events. Credit utilization. The number and recency of inquiries. And the overall pattern of how debt has been managed.

Score thresholds vary by program, with better pricing at higher tiers and meaningful pricing steps at defined breakpoints. Moving from just below a threshold to just above can change pricing materially, which makes it worth checking before applying.

Practical steps: pull your reports well before applying, dispute errors, pay down revolving balances before the statement date rather than after, and avoid opening new accounts during the process.

Liquidity and reserves

The requirement borrowers most often fail to anticipate.

Lenders require post-closing liquidity — funds remaining after the down payment and closing costs. Commonly expressed as months of payments on the subject property, and frequently on all financed properties.

Requirements increase with the number of properties owned, and can be substantial for investors with several.

Also relevant: the source and seasoning of funds. Large recent deposits require documentation. Funds must generally be seasoned in your accounts for a defined period, and gifts and loans have specific treatment.

Retirement accounts often count toward reserves at a discounted percentage.

Plan for this in advance. Moving money between accounts shortly before applying creates documentation work and sometimes problems.

Debt-to-income, and how rental income is treated

For conventional financing, the ratio of total monthly debt obligations to gross monthly income is a binding constraint.

The treatment of rental income is where investors are most often surprised.

Lenders generally do not count gross rent. They apply a vacancy and maintenance factor — commonly seventy-five percent of gross rent — and then subtract the full mortgage payment including taxes and insurance.

A property renting for $2,000 with a payment of $1,600 contributes $1,500 minus $1,600, which is negative $100 to your income calculation, despite cash-flowing positively in reality.

Documentation requirements also vary. Some programs require the rental income to appear on a filed tax return before it counts, which means a recently acquired property may not help your qualification for a year or more.

This is the mechanism by which investors with positive cash flow across a portfolio are told their debt-to-income ratio is too high, and it is the main reason investors migrate to portfolio and DSCR lending.

Experience

Relevant on commercial and investor-focused lending, and largely irrelevant on standard conventional loans.

Commercial lenders assess whether you have operated comparable property before. A first-time buyer of a thirty-unit building will find lenders cautious, and may need a more experienced partner or guarantor.

For renovation and construction lending, experience with comparable projects matters a great deal, and lenders will ask for a schedule of prior work.

Building a documented track record — a simple schedule of properties owned, purchase prices, current values, loan balances and operating performance — is worth maintaining continuously. Lenders ask for it, and having it ready signals competence.

The global cash flow analysis

Commercial lenders frequently perform this, and it surprises borrowers.

Rather than looking at the subject property alone, they assess your entire financial picture: all properties, all debt, all income, all guarantees.

A borrower whose subject property performs well but whose overall portfolio is stressed may still be declined.

This is another reason the portfolio-level view matters. Your lender takes it whether you do or not.

Entity and structure questions

If borrowing through an entity, lenders will want the formation documents, operating agreement, certificate of good standing, and identification of all members above a threshold ownership.

Some programs require a single-purpose entity holding only the subject property.

Ownership complexity slows things down. A straightforward structure closes faster.

Preparing the file

The borrowers who close smoothly are the ones with documents ready before they apply.

Two years of tax returns, personal and business. Recent pay stubs where applicable. Two to three months of bank and investment statements for all accounts. A current personal financial statement. A schedule of real estate owned, with details. Entity documents. Leases and rent rolls for existing properties. Insurance declarations.

Assembling this takes a day and saves weeks.

And answer document requests immediately. Files that stall usually stall because the borrower took four days to send a bank statement, three times.

General information about real estate finance, not lending or investment advice. Underwriting standards vary by lender and program and change over time. Consult qualified professionals about your own circumstances.

Alan Whitfield
Editor, Real Estate Investing Trends

Alan underwrote commercial real estate loans for eleven years. He now writes about the deals he would not have approved, and why people did them anyway.

More from Alan →

Also by Alan Whitfield

Financing

Paying off the mortgage early, or not

A question with a clear mathematical answer and a legitimate non-mathematical one, and the two frequently disagree.

Alan Whitfield··4 min read

Financing

Assumable loans and why they matter again

A low-rate mortgage attached to a property has become a significant asset in its own right, and a minority of loans allow it to transfer.

Alan Whitfield··4 min read

Strategies

REITs and the case for not owning buildings

Public real estate offers the exposure without the operations, and the comparison with direct ownership is more even than either side admits.

Nikhil Varma··3 min read