Real Estate Investing Trends
The numbers behind the property

Strategies

Tax Lien And Tax Deed Sales Compared

When property taxes go unpaid, some states sell a lien against the debt and others sell the property itself, and the two mechanisms produce entirely different outcomes.

High-rise residential building with balconies and multiple windows in an urban setting.
High-rise residential building with balconies and multiple windows in an urban setting. · Photo via Pexels
Financial information notice. Analysis and education — not personalised financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Local governments must collect property taxes to fund services, and when an owner does not pay, state law provides a mechanism to convert the delinquency into cash. Two broad systems exist.

The lien system

In lien states, the taxing authority sells a certificate representing the unpaid taxes. The buyer pays the delinquency and receives the right to collect it, with statutory interest, from the owner.

The owner keeps the property and may redeem by paying what is owed within a period defined by statute. Most certificates are redeemed rather than foreclosed.

If redemption does not occur within the period, the certificate holder may begin a process that can eventually lead to title, subject to further notice requirements.

The government's interest is served either way, since it receives the delinquent tax revenue at the sale and leaves the collection risk with the certificate holder.

The deed system

In deed states, the government forecloses its own claim and sells the property at auction. The buyer receives a deed rather than a certificate.

Some deed states allow a redemption period after the sale during which the former owner can reclaim the property, which delays the buyer's clear possession.

Bidding conventions vary. Some jurisdictions bid the price up, others bid the interest rate down, and a few use rotational or lottery systems.

What survives the sale

A tax sale does not necessarily extinguish every other claim. Certain federal liens, municipal charges and easements may continue to bind the property afterward.

Title obtained through a tax process is often not insurable immediately, and a further action may be required before the property can be sold or financed conventionally.

Buyers also generally cannot inspect the interior beforehand, so condition is unknown at the time of bidding.

Where the real work sits

Notice requirements are strict. A sale conducted without proper notice to the owner and to lienholders can be challenged later, sometimes years later.

Verifying assessments, other recorded interests and occupancy status before bidding is the substance of the exercise rather than a formality.

Occupancy in particular is often overlooked, because removing an occupant is a separate legal process with its own timeline and cost.

Why generalizations fail here

Interest rates, redemption periods, notice rules and the treatment of surplus funds are all set by state statute and local practice, and they are amended regularly.

A real estate attorney licensed in the specific state, consulted before participating, is the appropriate step. Practice in a neighboring county may not be the same.

Alan Whitfield
Editor, Real Estate Investing Trends

Alan underwrote commercial real estate loans for eleven years. He now writes about the deals he would not have approved, and why people did them anyway.

More from Alan →

Also by Alan Whitfield

Strategies

Wholesaling, and what it actually involves

Contracting a property and assigning the contract for a fee is a real business with a marketing engine at its centre and a growing set of legal constraints.

Alan Whitfield··4 min read

Strategies

The first deal: a realistic sequence

Not a formula for wealth, just the order of operations that most successful first purchases have followed.

Rosa Delgado··4 min read